Our Top Picks for Dark Exterior Paint Colors

I am such a sucker for dark exteriors! I think a lot of people love the look, but are scared to go that route, and understandable so. It’s a bold statement.

Although we will not be brave enough to go completely dark on our new build exterior, we will probably go darker on the trim and siding of the new house. We gave you a little preview on Instagram when we posted the last two Renders that Henry did.

Dark colors also pair very well when contrasting them with a lighter color. We will be doing a lighter color brick and darker siding with some wood and copper accents.

It’s important that before you choose your darker exterior paint color to keep a few things in mind. If you are painting the entire exterior a darker color, it tends to look slightly darker in larger areas. So you may want to choose just a tad lighter when doing such an expansive area. Another little tip is that we recommend using a flat finish for the exterior. When using a sheen it tends to show more imperfections, especially in the direct sunlight.

Here are our top contenders for dark exterior paint colors that we absolutely love. Now, choosing one for our exterior is going to be the challenge.

Benjamin Moore Iron Mountain

Credit: JHF Homes
Credit: Nicky Kehoe

Iron Mountain by Benjamin Moore is one of the top contenders for our new house. It is a somewhat of a darker gray brown. It is very warm and is another one I love seeing on the exterior of a home.

Sherwin Williams Black Magic

Credit: Rosewood Custom Builders

Black Magic by Sherwin Williams is normally seen on interior doors, but also looks magnificent on the exterior. It is a soft black that looks great paired with stained woods.

Benjamin Moore Black Panther

Credit: Remodelista

Black Panther by Benjamin Moore is another soft black that looks great for using both on interior and exteriors.

Sherwin Williams Domino

Domino by Sherwin Williams is not a pure black. It is a little softer with a touch of brown. I have noticed it is used lots for exterior front doors and it looks amazing!

Sherwin Williams Iron Ore

Credit: Pam Sessions

I have to say I’m loving Iron Ore, but I also love the homes that Pam Sessions of Hedgewood Homes is designing, and she uses Iron Ore a lot. This is probably one of our favorite top contenders at this time. I would describe it as a grayish black. I love that it isn’t too dark, but at the same time appears to have black tones. Although, when using it on the exterior in direct sun it will appear a little lighter.

Sherwin Williams Caviar

Caviar is another great one by Sherwin Williams. I would say it is more of a warmer soft black with gray undertones. It is for sure an eye catcher on the exterior.

Previous Post Next Post

You may also like


  • Reply Phyllis R Limiero

    We chose to paint our home with SW Gauntlet Gray with white trim and a bright blue front door. We love the look of the dark color and our gardens really shine against the gray.

    August 29, 2019 at 2:09 pm
    • Reply Brooke

      Hi Phyllis. I’m sure that looks amazing! That’s a great color as well.

      August 30, 2019 at 4:45 pm
  • Reply Sharolyn Schofield

    WoW! Perfect timing on this article…thanks! Just getting ready to choose colors for a teeny little 50’s style house in the woods…and it’s been hard to pick what really looks good from the paint samples! Thanks so much for the inspiration. -Sharolyn

    August 30, 2019 at 4:24 pm
    • Reply Brooke

      Hi Sharolyn. Thanks! Glad you found it helpful. Good luck on choosing your color.

      August 30, 2019 at 4:46 pm

    Leave a Reply